top of page

Judging Women in Relationships: The Woman You Judged Before You Became Her

Writer: Dr. Bindu Babu MD, PHD
Dr. Bindu Babu MD, PHD
Nov 10
7 min read

Sometimes life places us inside the very story we once believed we understood from the outside.


woman judgement-  The Woman You Judged Before You Became Her- Dr. Bindu Babu

By Dr. Bindu Babu


I would never stay.


I would never tolerate that.


I would never let someone treat me that way.


I would never get divorced.


I would never break up my family.


We say many things about lives we have never had to live.

And I know this because, surprisingly, a very long time ago, I was one of those women.


I had my own ideas about what I would and would not tolerate.

I thought I knew what strength looked like.

I thought I knew what I would do if someone betrayed me.

I thought I knew when a woman should stay, when she should leave, and what I would do differently if I were in her place.


There were things I was certain would never become part of my story.


But certainty comes easily when we are standing safely outside someone else's life.

Then life has a way of teaching us what opinions cannot.

Sometimes it places us inside the very circumstances we once judged from afar.


And suddenly—

you become the woman you once thought you understood.


When "I Would Never" Becomes Your Life


Maybe you believed you would leave the first time someone betrayed you.


Until the person who betrayed you was someone you had built a life with.

Someone you loved.

Someone whose hand you had held through difficult years.

Someone with whom you shared children, memories, a home, and a future you had already imagined.

Suddenly, betrayal isn't hypothetical anymore.


Neither is leaving.


Neither is staying.


The questions become different.


What if I still love him?

What about the children?

What if he really changes this time?

What happens to everything we built?

What if leaving is a mistake?

What if staying is?


That is when I began to understand something I could not have fully understood before:

It is very easy to know what you would do in a life you have never had to live.


For me, that woman eventually became myself.

And life looked very different from inside her story.


From the Outside, It Looks So Simple


Why doesn't she just leave?

Why does she keep forgiving him?

How can she not see what he's doing?

Why would she go back?


But relationships rarely unravel in one clean moment.


There can be pain followed by tenderness.


Cruelty followed by an apology.


Distance followed by affection.


Promises followed by disappointment—and then another promise that somehow makes you hope again.


And sometimes hope is what keeps a woman there.

Not because she cannot see what is happening.

But because she remembers who this person once was.

Because she remembers who they once were.

Because she keeps believing there is still something worth saving.

Sometimes we aren't holding onto the relationship as it is.


We are holding onto the belief that it could become what it once was—or what we always believed it could be.


From the outside, people see a decision.

From the inside, a woman may be trying to untangle an entire life.


Sometimes the Woman You Judged Was the Woman Who Stayed


Maybe you once believed strong women simply walked away.


Then life taught you that leaving isn't always one brave decision.


Sometimes a woman leaves emotionally long before she can leave physically.

Sometimes she is afraid.

Sometimes there are children.

Sometimes finances make leaving complicated.

Sometimes she has been manipulated for so long that she no longer completely trusts her own judgment.

And sometimes she simply isn't ready.

That doesn't make her weak.


Sometimes she is still trying to reconcile two versions of the same person:

the person she fell in love with and the person standing in front of her now.


I understand that differently today.

Because when you are living it, you don't experience a relationship as a list of everything that went wrong.


You experience the memories.

The history.

The good days mixed among the painful ones.

The promises.

The hope.

And the person you once believed you would grow old beside.


That is much harder to walk away from than people imagine.


And Sometimes You Judged the Woman Who Left


Maybe you once believed marriage was forever.

That families stayed together.

That good women worked through difficult seasons.

That children needed both parents under one roof.

Maybe those beliefs weren't entirely yours.

They may have been handed to you through family, culture, religion, community, or generations of women before you.


You may have learned that a good woman was patient.

Forgiving.

Understanding.

She compromised.

She kept private things private.

She thought about everyone else.

She held the family together.


So what happens when holding everything together begins to mean losing yourself?


When staying requires silence?


When keeping the peace means sacrificing your own?


When the woman trying desperately to save her family can barely recognize herself anymore?


At some point, the question changes.

It is no longer simply:

Why would she leave?


It becomes:

How much of herself is a woman expected to lose before leaving becomes acceptable?


Because staying costs something too.

Sometimes it costs peace.

Dignity.

Confidence.

Your voice.

Your sense of who you are.

Sometimes you become so focused on saving the relationship that you don't notice you are slowly disappearing inside it.


The Hardest Woman to Stop Judging May Be Yourself


This is the part we don't talk about enough.


You aren't only grieving what happened.

You may also be grieving the woman you thought you were.


I was smarter than this.


I should have known.


Why did I forgive so much?


Why did I stay so long?


How did I become this woman?


I understand those questions too.

But there comes a point when healing asks us to stop interrogating the woman we used to be.


She made decisions with what she understood then.

She loved with the heart she had then.

She hoped because she believed there was still something worth saving.

Maybe she stayed because she loved.

Maybe she stayed because she was afraid.

Maybe she wasn't ready.

Or maybe her heart simply needed more time to accept what her mind was beginning to understand.

And eventually, something changed.


Maybe clarity began replacing confusion.

Maybe the promises stopped being enough.

Maybe she started hearing her own voice again.

Maybe she looked at herself and realized she had become a shell of the woman she used to be.


Whatever brought her there—

she got you here.


Do not spend the rest of your life punishing her for not knowing then what it took you years to understand.


Judging Women in Relationships: When Life Humbles Our Certainty


There are experiences we understand intellectually.


And then there are experiences life makes us understand differently.


Betrayal.

Marriage.

Divorce.

Infidelity

Toxic relationships.

Motherhood.

Loneliness.

Loving someone who hurts you.

Leaving someone you may still love.


There was a time when I didn't fully understand how easy judging women in relationships could be when we were looking at their lives from the outside.


But once you have lived on both sides of that judgment, something inside you changes.


You become slower to ask:

Why doesn't she just leave?


Slower to say:

I would never.


And quicker to wonder:

What has she lived through that I cannot see?

What is she carrying?

What is she afraid of losing?

What part of herself is she still trying to find?


That may be one of the unexpected things pain teaches us.

Compassion for lives we once thought we understood.


The Woman I Once Judged


A very long time ago, I thought becoming that woman would mean something about me.

Maybe that I wasn't strong enough.

That I should have known better.

That I had somehow failed at something I once believed I understood.


I don't see her that way anymore.


Because life taught me something certainty never could.


She wasn't weak.

She wasn't foolish.

She wasn't lacking intelligence or strength.


She was a woman living a life I had never understood—until it became my own.


And perhaps that is why I am much more careful with the words "I would never " today.


Because we do not know what we would do inside a life we have never had to live.

We don't know the conversations that happen behind closed doors.

The nights someone cries alone.

The promises they believed.

The children they were trying to protect.

The hope they were holding onto.

Or how many times they tried before anyone else even knew there was something wrong.


So when I look at another woman now, I don't want to ask:

Why did she stay?

Why did she go back?

Why didn't she leave sooner?


I would rather ask:

What might she be carrying that I cannot see?


Because sometimes the woman you once judged becomes the woman who teaches you the most.

About love.

About strength.

About humility.

About compassion.

And about yourself.


I once thought becoming that woman would mean I had failed.


Today, I understand her differently.

I had to become her before I could truly understand her.


And somewhere along the way, I learned something even more important:

not to judge another woman for a life I have never had to live.


Dear Women

We may not always recognize the woman life asks us to become.

But sometimes healing begins when we stop judging her long enough to understand her.

And sometimes understanding her is how we finally learn to forgive ourselves.

With love, Dr. Bindu Babu


About Dr. Bindu Babu

Dr. Bindu Babu, MD, PhD, writes about women, relationships, self-worth, healing, and the often-unspoken experiences that can cause us to lose ourselves along the way.

Her work explores the complicated spaces between loving another person and loving yourself, staying and leaving, holding on and letting go—and what it means to find your way back to yourself when life does not unfold the way you once imagined.

Through her writing and work with women, Dr. Babu encourages women to move beyond shame and self-judgment, understand their experiences with greater clarity and compassion, and create lives rooted in self-respect, peace, and a stronger sense of self.


Dear Women

Dear Women is a weekly letter from Dr. Bindu Babu about healing, love, relationships, self-worth, and finding your way back to yourself.

A space for the conversations women often carry quietly—and a reminder that sometimes the most important relationship we rebuild is the one we have with ourselves.


One letter. Once a week. From me to you.


Comments


bottom of page